March 27, 2008

POZ Founder Sean Strub Responds to Swiss Statement on Condomless Sex

The Swiss Federal Commission for HIV/AIDS released a statement recently that claimed that HIV-positive people whose viral loads have been undetectable for at least six months and who do not have any other sexually transmitted diseases are “not sexually infectious.” The statement has created a widespread stir among activists, departments of health and governments worldwide. In response to the global discussion around the issues raised by the statement, POZ founder Sean Strub wrote an essay on the Huffington Post (huffingtonpost.com, 3/26) advocating that more thought should be given to developing safer-sex guidelines that include viral load as a factor that can reduce transmission risk.

“Interpreting the Swiss statement as ‘permission’ to stop using condoms would be a mistake,” he wrote. “So too would dismissing it altogether or denying its powerful message of hope.”

Strub says that a major response to the study has been skepticism about its validity. For example, some critics highlight the fact that the research was based on heterosexual couples, or that undetectable viral loads can sometimes spike unexpectedly. However, according to Strub, most critiques ignore the fact that the study demonstrates how antiretroviral therapy can be used as a piece of the HIV prevention puzzle.

“The Swiss have rightly brought viral load into the risk calculus, revolutionizing the paradigm of HIV prevention, and placing condoms in their proper place, as one tool among many to be utilized to prevent HIV transmission,” Strub wrote. “Failing to embrace the opportunity presented by the Swiss statement—to stimulate community discussion, improve the ability of individuals to accurately assess risk and encourage more research—is  irresponsible.”

NEW! Scroll down to comment on this story.

Name:	(2-50 characters)
Email:	(will not show)
City:	(optional)

Comment (500 characters left):

(Note: The POZ team review all comments before they are posted. Please do not include either ":" or "@" in your comment.)

| Posting Rules

Previous Comments:

Sam, , 2008-04-19 12:12:26
This country is full of ignores, lack of educations, and people live with HIV here more likely to be depressed because the ignores

Vladimir, San Diego, 2008-04-03 15:33:16
I am married to an HIV neg female. After religiously adhering to ARVs for 8 years and being married for 7 years, we decided to look for info on getting pregnant. The Swiss report was an important tool in making an informed decision, however, American doctors and researchers are apprehensive about releasing information or assisting serodiscordant couples with pre-natal issues. I understand our fear of HIV and lawsuits are to blame, but we need more research and assistance on the issue.

Craig, Jacksonville, 2008-04-01 21:44:59
I too was told by(2) Infectious Disease Primary Care Drs.in Miami that I could have safe sex w/ out use of condom now that my numbers were above 600 t-cells & undetectable for over 1 year. I do have safe sex but these doctors were so proud to tell me regardless of what others thought- I was brave going back on meds so I would not infect others if it came to be. Just wanted to share this - it is not just in Switzerland-it is in America. Is there evidance it is present in semen of healthy men?

Jamie, New York, 2008-03-28 12:14:57
I greatly appreciate your observations in regard to the Swiss Statement. Just to entertain the possibility of having bare intercourse with my wife--after 15 years of condoms--is exhilarating. I find the Swiss arguement scientifically sound and measured. The dismissal by WHO and UNAIDS is a serious mistake.