The HIV dissident movement may prove to be an
unlikely but deciding factor in the highest-profile congressional race
of this year's election. In July, New York City newspapers reported
that Rep. Rick Lazio (R-NY) -- in a nasty neck-and-neck with First Lady
Hillary Clinton for New York's open Senate seat -- wrote a letter to
the chair of the House Appropriations subcommittee requesting $2.5 million
for veteran viral naysayers The Group for the Scientific Reappraisal
of the HIV Hypothesis of AIDS. At a press briefing, Clinton said she
was "shocked" to hear of Lazio's assistance. "It shows how out of touch
he is with the mainstream of New York," she said.
For weeks afterward, the Lazio camp defended
his actions, claiming that he had only wanted to help the group as constituents
and "AIDS sufferers." They pointed out that even AIDS agitators Housing
Works acknowledged his HOPWA advocacy. But Clinton campaign spokesperson
Howard Wolfson said the damage goes deeper. "It displayed a real ignorance
of the issue," he said. "It's unfortunate that Lazio's campaign doesn't
just admit it's a terrible mistake and apologize for it."
Some AIDS activists, however, said accusations
that Lazio actually supports the denialist position are probably unfounded,
with one explaining Lazio is "not a genius -- or even a very smart guy."
(The activist, who works for an agency that receives federal funds for
which Lazio must vote, asked not to be identified.) Although recently
slammed for voting against international pediatric AIDS funding, he
got a congressional voting score of 60 percent last year from the Washington,
DC-based advocacy group AIDS Action. "For a Republican, that's pretty
good," said AIDS Action's Denis Dison. "But if he knew about the dissidents'
beliefs and still did this, then it's complete recklessness. I think
it's probably bad staff work."
A Lazio staffer confirmed this scenario, telling
POZ that Lazio didn't even know about the group or the
letter when it was originally sent. "Congressional staffs are small
and overworked," said the source, noting that some 200 similar requests
are made each year by the representative. No one from Lazio's office
itself would speak on the record about the issue.
Missing the chance to diss the dissidents when
they had the chance may be the most lasting result of the whole mess,
one of the only times AIDS has been mentioned at all in this race. Said
Dison, "Instead of saying they made a mistake -- which I think people
would understand -- they're complicating matters by toeing the denialist
party line, saying their voices should be heard."