April 19, 2013
Why Tyler Perry's Temptation Kills Women With HIV
by Naina Khanna
An HIV-positive woman argues the film preys on the worst fears of people with HIV.
I have been sitting with and following the reactions to Tyler Perry's Temptation over the last couple weeks. Within the HIV community, and outside of it. Within the feminist community, and in other communities of women. In communities of color, among reproductive justice folks, and outside of those spaces.
What has been most distressing to me is the way that Tyler Perry played on and abused the high levels of internalized stigma and oppression, evident in responses from women of color and women living with HIV with respect to the film. [In the movie, the character of Judith cheats on her husband and she contracts HIV from the other man.]
"She chose to leave Bryce." "She made a choice to put herself at risk." "She wasn't grateful enough for what she had, so she deserved it." "Harley is a monster, like the monster who infected me." These are only a smattering of the comments I've seen, read, and heard over the last weeks.
My reaction to witnessing the dialogue among HIV-positive women is the same motivation that originally drove a group of 28 women to co-found Positive Women's Network-USA in 2008, rejecting the seemingly widespread notion that women living with HIV were forever destined to be held up as examples and nothing more.
That our place in the HIV workforce, public health community and education efforts was relegated to storytellers regaling classrooms, legislative chambers, and church congregations with tales of our supposed guilt, sins, and transgressions, and, sometimes worse, of our supposed innocence.
Worse, women living with HIV seemed to largely accept our place in that structure. We are incentivized to be complicit in it for a $25 or $50 stipend every World AIDS Day and the occasional Sunday. How do you resist a paradigm when living on a fixed income and feeding your family—and even making sense of your own reality—may depend on your willingness to participate in it?
Watching Temptation was triggering to me, as a woman of color living with HIV, because it preys on the worst fears and internalized self-loathing of people who are most likely to be living with HIV. Tyler Perry's Temptation teaches that:
1. I'm a woman, so I don't know if or when I want sex. If I say no, I don't mean it, and when I say no, it's because I am trying to live up to a societal expectation that women should say no, even if we don't mean it. Therefore a man has the right to interpret my "no" and to rape me based on his decision that I did not really mean "NO!" This final (and archaic) portrayal might be the one that most directly and thoroughly assaults the self-worth of women living with HIV. Patriarchy, family structures, and cultural codes teach us from an early age that women without partners and without children hold little stature in family and society, especially in communities of color.
2. Men with HIV are sexually irresponsible, predatory and violent, and fail to disclose.
3. As a woman, I should be so afraid of the big bad world that I should not dare consider leaving my relationship. (Also, it's a slippery slope from teetotaler to using cocaine regularly.)
4. People living with HIV cannot even hope for loving relationships, let alone have them, no matter how long they live with HIV. Romance, sex, love, and children? Off the table entirely.
Most women living with HIV in the United States are women of color and poor women, who already live at the intersection of multiple oppressions before their HIV diagnosis.
Thus, for a woman testing positive for HIV, or who suspects she may be HIV positive, motherhood and/or becoming a spouse or partner may be the only socially valued identity available to her.
If Tyler Perry's portrayal is real, and we are sinful, secretive monsters, unworthy of love and incapable of reproduction, what is the incentive for any woman to learn that she is HIV-positive and for any person living with HIV to disclose her/his status?
Research and data discredit every one of Perry's points about people living with HIV, not to mention the assumptions about who may be at risk for HIV. Studies show that the overwhelming majority of people living with HIV practice safer sex once they know their HIV status. HIV-positive people date, and more often than not, seem to disclose, and many are in long-term relationships with HIV-negative or positive partners and spouses. Oh, and by the way—yes, we can have children! (Hello, 1990s.)
However, the majority of folks who encounter people living with HIV may not know this information, and certainly the majority of folks testing positive for HIV do not initially have complete information, and thus Perry's portrayal is dangerous, deceptive and misleading. Perpetuating HIV stigma creates obvious problems in expanding HIV testing and ensuring that people living with HIV are in medical care and are safe disclosing to their partners.
But most of Perry's messages have already been largely internalized by women living with HIV, as evidenced in the troubling response among many HIV-positive women to Temptation.
It's just not that simple. Let me say it: It sucks to be cheated on or lied to. And sometimes people do irresponsible things, stupid things, hurtful things. Sometimes they thought about it beforehand and sometimes they didn't. It is irrelevant. HIV is not punishment for sins, bad behavior, insensitivity, irresponsibility, or naiveté. Lots of people do shitty things and do not get HIV. That is also irrelevant.
HIV is not something that "guilty" people get. It is not a punishment for cheating, lying, using drugs or alcohol, having more than one partner, not asking the right question, or not appreciating a partner enough.
HIV is also not something that people "innocently" get. HIV is a disease transmitted by four bodily fluids. Nobody "deserves" HIV or "doesn't deserve" HIV, just like nobody deserves or does not deserve cancer. And most of us didn't get HIV by having sex with the devil.
Also, love, eternal happiness, husbands and children are not shiny little prizes you win by being faithful or having sex only with the lights off.
Temptation is sleazy, trashy entertainment designed to profit by preying on our collective worst fears.
Innocence implies that guilt is possible, and guilt implies that innocence is possible. One is meaningless without the other. Allowing ourselves, as people living with HIV, to fall into any such dichotomy perpetuates the story that there are people who "deserve" a disease and its consequences—and worse, that it is permissible to hold any one of us up as an example to moralize. It's just not that simple. Let's not let Tyler Perry convince us it is.
But, there are conditions that put people at increased risk for poor health, and those are things we can and should work to change.
We ought to be angry with the laws, policies and norms that make it acceptable for companies to dump toxic waste in poor communities, increasing cancer rates.
We ought to be furious with the HIV criminalization laws, policies and social norms that make it challenging, even dangerous, to disclose one's HIV status. A bill passed in Kansas last month expanded authority of state and local health officials to quarantine people living with HIV. Larry Dunn's false beliefs about HIV led him to brutally murder his girlfriend after she disclosed her status. A man in Peru allegedly set fire to his HIV-positive gay son earlier this week. And over 32 states in the United States have laws criminalizing people with HIV at this time.
Countless people living with HIV and advocates throughout the nation are working to change these laws, bills, and stigmatizing beliefs. Among them, the Sero Project and the Positive Justice Project have advocated tirelessly to repeal laws and change policies that criminalize and stigmatize people living with HIV in the United States. The Positive Women's Network-USA has a treasure trove of resources produced by HIV-positive women framing a policy and communications dialogue that uplifts human rights and dignity.
Tyler Perry, on the other hand, exemplifies an irresponsible mouthpiece that preys on the fears, myths, misperceptions, and misguided policies we seek to reverse. Media has the power to change how we feel about ourselves and each other. Perry's messages keep people living with HIV closeted, fearful, and isolated. They kill us.
It is this fear of ourselves and what we represent that is depressing, that makes us slowly lose the will to live, to fight, to leave unhealthy or dangerous relationships, to take our medication, to get to the doctor one more time.
It is our own worst fear that Tyler Perry's portrayal of us—a story told over and over—is real, and that the best we have to hope for is a sexy, sweet, remarried ex who will ask us about our T-cell count.
And just maybe, the messages portrayed by Tyler Perry are the reason why many women living with HIV in the United States are not in regular medical care.
It takes a very, very long time to undo decades of media and public health officials and faith based institutions telling us that people living with HIV are getting what we deserve. It takes even longer to undo the internalized oppression that comes from colonization and slavery and displacement. And I cannot imagine how long it will take women to undo internalized sexism and its deadly consequences.
For the estimated 300,000 women living with HIV in the United States, Tyler Perry's Temptation preys on the worst of all that. For this, I charge him with at least 300,000 counts of self-doubt and recrimination, a million moments of fear and hopelessness, hundreds of failures to disclose, countless refused HIV tests, thousands of missed medical appointments, suicides, homicides, and setting us back in our HIV response for over than a decade.
Tyler Perry must commit to doing better. Call PWN-USA and the U.S. People Living with HIV Caucus before you make your next movie on HIV. Otherwise, someone, please take away that camera.
Naina Khanna is executive director of the Positive Women’s Network – United States of America (PWN-USA). This op-ed is her personal perspective and does not necessarily reflect the views of PWN-USA.
Search: Tyler Perry, Temptation, women, Naina Khanna
Scroll down to comment on this story.
comments 30 - 44 (of 46 total)
Jeanine, Newark, 2013-04-25 17:39:53
Please stop making everything political. Its a movie,I love Tyler Perry and the messages he displays in his craft.I live with HIV,I watched the movie with my HIV positive partner.We enjoyed the movie and walked away from it saying...that sh#t still happens to our sisters. Tyler wrote the truth.....
Demetria Mallard, galveston, 2013-04-24 04:26:28
I have had to much respect for Tyler and all his movies and appreciated the fact that he even addressed the issue of HIV, but for him to show the irresponsibility that he shows in this movie is appalling. Anyone living with this, and doing what they are supposed to do will never pass this on to anyone, especially, not any "two". It's ridiculous, and I am living with it and have changed my whole life around and no one will ever say that I gave them HIV. Show responsibility, not irresponsibilit
Zimkhitha, Johannesburg, 2013-04-24 01:37:17
I have not watched the movie but I have found help when I least expected it.Im a christian been living with Hiv for over 10 years and unfortunately for me I thouoght the best place to start with disclosure would be my pastors.That did not go well and ever since then I have carried guilt in my heart which I believe today is being released.The sermons for the two years I remained in that congregation were always about how "you will certainly pay for sleeping around","we know you are here"
Joshua King, Utica, 2013-04-23 14:51:32
So I have to defend Tyler Perry's decision to highlight a major issue within the communities of color. I applaud him for his use of real life situations, which clearly are thought provoking and have affected you enough to write this piece. His direction is meaningful and purposeful. I feel that he was attempting to clarify many of the social norms and stigma attached to HIV. You raise excellent points about your interpretation, however please note that he has achieved his goal...discussion.
April 35, SanLeandro, 2013-04-22 17:17:32
Why would you take shots at Tyler Perry, the movie was not focused on or about HIV/AIDS read the title Temptation !!!!!
gottaberesilient1, , 2013-04-22 16:57:21
Well said, I give you a standind up for all that you have said. It has always been a way for God to shine his meaning of Love. I feel that someone should also utilize their God given resource of working in the field of the White House and make aware to our President of this letter. It has many powerful points of HIV way beyond Tyler. I am trusting that this reaches All the Hearts of the Powers that be; to begin the path of a Healthier epidemic of HIV/AIDS. May this be so in The Name of Jesus..
Denise, Canada, 2013-04-21 14:44:17
This is quite simply the best column I have ever read on how women are treated with HIV. It takes guts to leave a relationship when you have HIV. It is terrible how HIV women are paid pathetic amounts to tell their story and educate others and the guilt that they feel if they don't. Thank you for telling it like it is!
AladinSane, , 2013-04-21 01:04:54
My only questions, not having seen the film and certainly not a fan of TP so I'm not likely to, is HOW does he represent those with HIV in the way that you state? Give specific examples. It isn't enough to say that he does so to those of us who haven't seen the film. WHY are we supposed to feel this is valid criticism? From reading this post the only information I get, other than people's reaction, is that a wife cheated on her husband and got HIV. WHERE is the link? I ask all this earnestly.
Paul Klees, San Francisco, 2013-04-21 00:29:58
Did anyone expect anything approaching decent, mature, thoughtful writing from Tyler Perry? His portrayals of...anyone...are at best juvenile and at worst mysoginist. I am not surprised at all by this. Disappointed and shocked but NOT surprised. His comedies aren't funny, so why should his thoughtful work be thoughtful? He's been trashing women since he started.
Monique, , 2013-04-20 16:55:00
Thanks so much for that insight. I respect what you say in this article.TRUTH!!
Teresa Sullivan, Philadelphia, 2013-04-20 11:47:53
Thanks Naina for writing a powerful article that sets the record straight on women living with HIV, and that once one find out their HIV status and is educated In the science of transmission of HIV, they practice safe sex when having sex with their partners. Furthermore, HIV is not something that GOD will give human beings for making mistakes in our lives. HIV is virus and today with ARVs if adhenance is practiced, 96% less likely to transmitted the Virus to their partners. Thanks Naina.
Frederick Wright, Coachella Valley, 2013-04-20 08:25:57
Wow, a lot of words and beautiful this woman of color named, Naine Kanna in both her person and words of action and fierceness to speak the truth to power. When much is given Mr Perry, than much is expected, please hear the pains of the WOMAN and please act for social justice, for all people for can you not hear the pain the injustice? Stand up Man and Act with Honor and Hope for the children to include the WOMAN. Please for this Man of God begs you, pleads with your sprit to act for healing
Branden Mikal Dudek, Pittsburgh, 2013-04-20 05:13:01
Wow, wow, wow ... How brilliantly stated. I'm a bit speechless, you've covered this issue from every angle and I love it, you are magnificent!
Nancy Asha Molock, Philadelphia, 2013-04-20 00:42:45
Thank you Naina for your message.I was insulted by the distasteful portrayal of HIV positive people especially of the women in the movie Temptation. HIV positive women come from all walks of life, we are not one dimensional.We are not shameful, unempowered, lonely old maids as portrayed in the movie. Many HIV positive men and women are productive and are doing great things to contribute to the good of society.HIV positive women are strong,empowered,beautiful and deserving of the best in life.
pozblksister70, Oakland, 2013-04-19 18:30:05
comments 30 - 44 (of 46 total)
Thank you Naina for speaking up and being a voice for those of us who ask no pardon for our status, and refuse to let others in the midst of their ignorance condemn us to a life of shame, seclusion, fear and self-loathing. I haave not seen Temptation and based on what I read, I doubt that it something I would pay to see, let alone see on a date. Disclosure is difficult and dangerous enough without misinformation being spread like gospel when it is really garbage! Pozblksister
[Go to top]