December #30 : "The First Cure" - by Mike Barr

POZ - Health, Life and HIV
Subscribe to:
POZ magazine
Join POZ: Facebook MySpace Twitter Pinterest
Tumblr Google+ Flickr MySpace
POZ Personals
Sign In / Join

Back to home » Archives » POZ Magazine issues

Table of Contents

Wild Kingdom

Rx Marijuana

Gender Matters

The Fabulous One



Resistance Gets a Wellcome

Name in Vain

Go Figure

Like Butt-ah

An Aye for an Eye

To Russia Without Love

The Odd Couple

Secondhand Dose

Law and Disorder

AIDS in 2003

Catholic Cleanup

Until the Cure

Say What--December 1997

Diana, Princess of Wales

Chaka Treatment

Bear Essentials

Brace Yourself

All That Jazz

Respect Your Elders!

Bill of Health

Nunz With Attitude

POZ Picks-December 1997

Don't Mess With Mama

All Yesterday's Parties

The Light Burns Out

Peace of My Heart

Swing Your Partner

Once Upon a Lazarus

The Grim Reefer

In Case of Emergency

A DJ Saved My Life

Sweetness and Blight

"The First Cure"

Breaks for the Aches

Fishing for Supplements

When HIV Drugs Fail

Mary Fisher Gets Mad

Music Is Medicine

Most Popular Lessons

The HIV Life Cycle


Herpes Simplex Virus

Syphilis & Neurosyphilis

Treatments for Opportunistic Infections (OIs)

What is AIDS & HIV?

Hepatitis & HIV

email print

December 1997

"The First Cure"

by Mike Barr

The real drama may be off-stage

This may be a parable about the vanity and futility of looking where the light is. Also about the virtue of independent thinking and the reward that awaits a true pioneer. Last summer, the Aaron Diamond AIDS Research Center's first "eradication" candidate was scheduled to stop his therapy. After nearly two years on a triple combo, this twentysomething North Carolinian had no detectable HIV in his body; nor could any virus be cultured from his cells. Dodge, as he was called, was featured on a special Nightline segment. "Just one name," the reporter said, "like Madonna or Prince." The show was headlined "The First Cure." But even as the Aaron Diamond team was about to take Dodge off his unpalatable potion to test whether the "cure" had worked, scientists at Johns Hopkins called with disappointing news. After artificially stimulating some of Dodge's cells in the lab, they made his virus grow anew. If this could happen in a petri dish, they said, it could happen in Dodge's body. The first cure was not meant to be.

What the Nightline program didn't report was that a similar experiment had already been conducted in France-with much more stunning results. In an ongoing study with the combination of ddI and the 30-year-old cancer chemotherapy hydroxyurea, an Argentinian physician based in Lyons named Dr. Jorge Vila had identified two patients who, after 12 months of treatment, had no detectable HIV in their lymph nodes or blood. The two hale fellows agreed to stop therapy. That was in 1995. Nearly two years later, Vila and his colleagues report no rebound of HIV; nor can they grow virus from test-tube cells.

These results are remarkable: Never before has anyone gone off treatment and kept HIV at bay. In fact, according to current estimates, fully suppressive therapy would have to be given for between three and six years-and possibly for life. The authors propose that hydroxyurea's success is due to its ability to penetrate viral reservoirs-the "resting" CD4 cells and macrophages that the popular triple combos can't reach. A drug from the pharmaceutical house that brought us ddI and d4T, hydroxyurea is a neglected child for one simple reason: Bristol-Myers Squibb's patent on it expired in 1995, so no one's gonna get rich. (The drug may also cause leukemia and make your hair fall out.) Bristol-Myers recently decided not to finance further research with hydroxyurea.

Although exciting, what all this means remains unclear. It's inaccurate to say that HIV has been eradicated from these two patients: Both still harbor viral DNA. Vila claims that this DNA is defective and incapable of making new virus-a plausible hypothesis. But it's less likely, at least for now, that these results can be reproduced in many others. The two men were best-case eradication candidates: Recently infected, treated with no HIV meds prior to ddI/hydroxyurea, extremely low viral loads even before therapy. Other experiments with ddI and hydroxyurea have shown that at most 40 percent of patients go "undetectable." People with relatively high viral loads almost certainly will not.

Inarguably the Rodney Dangerfield of HIV therapeutics (there's no money behind it), hydroxyurea is often viewed with impatient disdain by doctors and activists on the triple-drug-cocktail circuit. In fact, the therapy garnered not even a footnote in the recently issued federal treatment guidelines. Rather than targeting HIV directly-as is the vogue in drug development-hydroxyurea inhibits an enzyme inside the body's own cells, which the virus needs to multiply. And since cellular therapies such as hydroxyurea act on relatively staid human cells-rather than quick-change HIV itself-the emergence of resistance (and drug failure) is much less likely.

Caveats aside, one immutable fact remains: Two HIV-infected people were treated for a year with two drugs (neither a protease inhibitor), went "undetectable," stopped therapy and almost two years later show no signs of viral reproduction. Is there something unique to hydroxyurea (and other cellular-enzyme inhibitors) responsible for this apparent success? Or will Dodge soon go off treatment and see the same results? Time's "Man of the Year" may be the first to show eradication. Or we may look back on this tiny study of a slighted drug in another country as the true "first cure." Or perhaps that dream will remain only a titilating title in the land of nighttime TV.

All I know is this: The obvious answer isn't always the true one; the popular approach is rarely the most effective; and the quick fix, ever so alluring, often doesn't last. If I were a more brazen risk-taker, I'd bet on a hydroxyurea-like drug. If only because it seems to overcome so perfectly the limitations of current therapies-and it's a little-noticed drama unfolding off-stage, where the bright light, big money and hubbub are not.

[Go to top]

Facebook Twitter Google+ MySpace YouTube Tumblr Flickr Instagram
Quick Links
Current Issue

HIV Testing
Safer Sex
Find a Date
Newly Diagnosed
HIV 101
Disclosing Your Status
Starting Treatment
Help Paying for Meds
Search for the Cure
POZ Stories
POZ Opinion
POZ Exclusives
Read the Blogs
Visit the Forums
Job Listings
Events Calendar
POZ on Twitter

Ask POZ Pharmacist

Talk to Us
Has a pet helped you deal with your HIV?


more surveys
Contact Us
We welcome your comments!
[ about Smart + Strong | about POZ | POZ advisory board | partner links | advertising policy | advertise/contact us | site map]
© 2016 Smart + Strong. All Rights Reserved. Terms of use and Your privacy.
Smart + Strong® is a registered trademark of CDM Publishing, LLC.