November 3, 2009

Prosecutors Deem HIV a Weapon in Michigan Assault Case

Daniel Allen, an HIV-positive Clinton Township, Michigan, man who allegedly bit his neighbor’s lip during a dispute, faces up to 15 years in prison on charges of assault with intent to maim, assault with intent to commit great bodily harm and possession or use of a harmful device; prosecutors claimed he intentionally tried to transmit HIV to his neighbor, The Detroit News reports.

“He knew he was HIV positive, and he bit the guy,” said Clinton Township District Court Judge Linda Davis in a November 2 preliminary hearing. “That on its own shows intent.”

The alleged victim, Winfred Fernandis Jr., said he confronted Allen on October 18 about a disagreement concerning a football some area children threw into Allen’s yard. The two men have been involved in several confrontations during the past five years.

“He came toward me and attacked me,” Fernandis said in court. “Then he bit me on the lip. His face was right next to mine, and I heard him growl.”

Allen’s attorney, James Galen Jr., claimed that Fernandis and his family members beat Allen because he is gay. Galen also has pictures of the injuries his client sustained during the fight. According to court records, Allen has filed for personal protection orders against Fernandis and his wife.

Allen is scheduled to undergo a pretrial and arraignment November 16 in Macomb County Circuit Court. He has also been ordered to submit a blood test to verify his HIV status.

Search: assault, biting, Michigan, Clinton Township, weapon, criminalization

Scroll down to comment on this story.

Previous Comments:

michigan22, Harrison Township, 2009-11-04 13:57:44
Criminalizing someone who has HIV, is repulsive. In this article, it seems as if MR. Allen has been a victim of hate crimes from the other family for some time. Hopefully new legislation signed into law helps his cause. Also, if people with HIV are going to be criminalized, why not begin criminalizing those who know they have swine flu and go into public and sneeze. They know they have it and it, it is very contagious, and is also very deadly. HIV criminalization laws need to be re-thought.